Yeah I'm going to go ahead and steal this idea because I am just the worst at gift selection and I have too much stuff going on right now to do my usual Process™. Look through my pets/items and name some things you think are neat and I will draw from this pool to distribute gifts.
It's like...really hard for me to judge how willing I'm going to be to part with a given thing until someone asks about it, so I cannot predict what the results of this will be! I'm terrible and riddled with indecision! But I think those are probably known facts. I will say stuff that has an actual name is less likely to be up for grabs but like...yeah that's also pretty straightforward.
Have at it. I will do my best to fulfill your wishes.